Best Toasters (2 and 4 slice) in Canada: Top Picks for Your Perfect Morning Breakfasts
This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen products, which earn us a commission at no additional cost for you. Learn More
What can be better than enjoying a fresh, crispy toast in the morning?
Well, maybe adding a little butter on top…
If you (just like me) can’t imagine your breakfast without toasts, check my list of the best toasters in Canada and the buying tips. Let’s find out which model can help make your mornings better!
A Quick Preview
- 5 browning settings to control the crispiness of your toasts;
- metal body, durable and easy to clean;
- 900-Watt power rating, browns the bread fast;
- Lift and Look feature to check the bread browning without interrupting the cycle;
- Bagel and Defrost features for a more versatile use.
The first model that deserves to be called one of the best toasters in Canada is the Breville, which is a compact 2-slice model that comes with a few handy features like browning controls and fast heating. Moreover, the Breville uses a durable die-cast metal body. It’s easy to clean too, all you have to do is wipe the exterior. There’s also a handy Lift and Look feature that allows users to sneak a peek at the bread to check how brown it is without stopping the cycle.
Based on Our Tests
While testing, I loved the monitor feature of this Breville 2-slice toaster, as it allowed me to check my toasts without stopping the cycle. I also liked that its wide slots can take various bread sizes.
- Durable construction
- Compact design, perfect for smaller living spaces
- Multiple browning options
- Has a Bagel and a Defrost feature
- Toasting progress indicator (LED) for your convenience
- Extra-wide slots for thicker bread slices and easier cleaning
- It probably wouldn’t appeal to people who only want simplicity out of their toaster.
- May toast one side more than the other depending on the setting.
- 6 browning settings for different toast types;
- brushed stainless steel exterior, durable and sleek-looking;
- wide slots for thicker bread slices and easy cleaning;
- extra-lift carriage lever for easy removal, especially good for larger slices;
- suitable for bagels, frozen pancakes, toaster pastries, and more, so you can enjoy various breakfasts.
The next toaster that deserves your attention is this 4-slice model by Cuisinart, which is ideal for families and couples. This toaster heats up fast and offers consistently good performance. It can accommodate thicker bread slices and also bagels, French toasts, pancakes, and more. You can control how brown you want your bread to get using a simple knob and watching a convenient LED indicator. Cleaning should also be easy as there’s a sliding removable crumb tray and wide bread slots.
Based on Our Tests
I think the Cuisinart CP-180 4-slice toaster would be a great choice for serving small gatherings. In addition, its multiple browning option means you get varying toastings simultaneously. However, a feature I particularly liked while testing the toaster was the extra-lift feature, as it came in handy when I toasted a large loaf, allowing me to remove a piece of stuck bagel easily.
- Durable stainless steel construction.
- Wide slots for different types of bread and pastry.
- 4 slots, ideal for couples and families.
- Multiple browning adjustments for versatile breakfasts.
- Extra Lift feature for easy removal
- Perfect for people who want to be able to control everything about their toasts.
- Uneven toasting is possible occasionally depending on the bread and the chosen setting
- uncommon blue exterior, can spruce your kitchen up;
- 6 shade settings for extra control over your toasts;
- wide slots for different types of bread;
- Defrost feature for frozen pancakes, bread, or even pastries;
- cord storage underneath the unit for convenience.
If you want to find a cute, unusual toaster in Canada, you should definitely consider this vintage-looking model by Keenstone. The blue exterior will add a splash of color to your kitchen and might even give it a fresher look. This toaster doesn’t only look good though. It comes with a set of handy features, including a defrost function, convenient wide slots, and adjustable browning settings.
Based on Our Tests
While trying to review the Keenstone toaster, I was able to create space for the toaster without having to clear my kitchen counter, and this is despite me using a small kitchen. So, I think this Keenstone toaster would be a good choice for users with limited counter space because of its compact design, anti-slide grip, and wire-storage slot.
- Uncommon blue exterior, ideal for people looking to spruce their kitchen up a bit
- Extra-wide slots for different bread types and easier cleaning
- Convenient cord storage
- Multiple shade settings
- Anti-slip rubber feet for safety and convenience
- Simple controls and LED indicators, user-friendly design
- Might not make the bread brown enough, according to some users and based on their preferences
- 7 browning levels for different users’ preferences;
- wide toasting slots for easy cleanups and to work with different types of bread;
- drop-down crumb tray for easy maintenance;
- minimalistic black exterior, would fit into pretty much any kitchen style;
- bagel setting for a more versatile use.
Looking for a new toaster but don’t have much money to spend? The Black + Decker will take care of that, as this toaster is super affordable but comes with all the essential features for a perfect toast. There are 7 shade settings for different browning levels. You can also enjoy a Bagel feature, for those days when you want something extra. The Extra Lift lever will protect your fingers from the heat and can come in handy when toasting thicker slices that don’t pop out that easily.
Based on Our Tests
The Black + Decker toaster is a versatile machine that can serve various toast preferences with its 7-shade browning option. I tested the seven shades, and each toast came out distinct. Interestingly, this versatile machine comes at an affordable price, making it ideal for budget shoppers.
- Simple and efficient, instead of complicated and confusing.
- Multiple shade adjustments for extra control over your breakfast.
- Easy to clean.
- Sleek-looking, will fit into any interior.
- Suitable for bagels and thicker bread slices.
- May not be as durable as more expensive competitors
Types of Toasters
Shopping for a new toaster in Canada, you may encounter different types, each of which has its benefits. To help you understand what type would work for you, let’s take a closer look at them:
- 2-slice. Such pop-up toasters are among the most popular models on the market. As the name suggests, they allow users to toast 2 slices of bread simultaneously. It’s an ideal option for solo users or those who have smaller kitchens and limited counter space. 2-slice toasters are usually cheaper, so they would suit budget shoppers as well. However, this type is generally quite limited in terms of controls and adjustments.
- 4-slice. Again, as the name implies, this type works to toast 4 slices of bread at the same time. Such toasters are perfect for larger households and families. It’s also a good option for hasty mornings when your family doesn’t have the time to wait for each person’s bread to brown. 4-slice toasters are a bit more expensive and require more counter space. Some of them allow for separate controls for each 2 pieces of bread, which lets users brown each pair to the desired extent.
- Toaster oven. This type might resemble a combination of a microwave and a regular toaster. Toaster ovens can also bake or defrost food, which makes them very versatile and popular among many users (1). Generally, toaster ovens take up more space than regular models. And while you can still find smaller options, keep in mind that they also have a smaller capacity, which isn’t ideal if you plan to use your toaster oven for baking too.
- Long-slot. Such toasters have longer slots (usually one or two) that can accommodate 2 slices of bread each (2). Long-slot models are not that common, but since they are a bit on the thinner side, they work great for smaller kitchens. They are also quite easy to clean, as larger slots typically allow for easier access.
Things to Look for When Buying a Toaster in Canada
Navigating among the best toasters in Canada can be quite confusing as they all vary depending on the features, design, and multiple other aspects. So, let’s check the most important factors to help you narrow your list down:
- Type. As you already know, there are multiple types of toasters you can come across. If you are a solo user and don’t need to brown more than 2 slices of bread simultaneously, then a 2-slice model should suffice. Families typically pick larger models with bigger capacity, such as toaster ovens or 4-slice toasters.
- Slot size. Some models come with slots that can accommodate thicker slices of bread. Such toasters are also slightly easier to clean as you have a wider opening for the bread.
- Maintenance. Firstly, it’s better to pick a toaster with a crumb tray that is easy to remove. Additionally, if the ease of cleaning is very important to you, you may want to opt for a model with wider bread slots and a non-stick interior. It may also be a good idea to pick a toaster with an exterior that doesn’t have any tricky curves or crevices where the dirt can accumulate.
- Controls. If the toaster you are considering is more than just basic and allows for adjustments, it should be easy to operate. Therefore, the controls have to be simple and easy to read. Most importantly, the control buttons have to be positioned away from the hot areas of the toaster.
- Power rating. Measured in watts, the power rating can give you a rough idea of how fast the toaster can brown the bread. More powerful models typically take less time and make crisper toasts. Low-wattage toasters often make the bread chewy instead of crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside.
- Exterior. Firstly, consider the color if you want it to match your kitchen design. The majority of toasters come in neutral colors like white, silver, or black. However, there are manufacturers that offer brighter solutions, so if you want your new device to stand out, you can pick an uncommon color. Pay attention to the material as well. While plastic is a popular choice among many manufacturers, steel exteriors are more durable.
- The material. There are both plastic ones among toasters and metallic ones. Some people think the plastic ones are not good. But the truth is that they are not any different, and the quality of the toast is not going to be any different either.
- Extra features. If your budget allows for it, you can shop for a more expensive model that comes with a few bells and whistles. For instance, there are toasters that allow users to toast their bread longer than regular models. Others have a keep-warm function, which would keep your bread warm until you are ready to eat it. Some toasters come with digital displays, variable temperature, defrost function, bagel setting, and so on.
The bagel setting would be best for when you need only the inside of your bagel toasted and the outside kept warm. This would be a more complicated option for some toasters, but if you don’t mind spending extra bucks, this can be the perfect setting for you. Sometimes, there is also a defrost option that may come in handy many times. Sometimes you would just need to defrost your bread or waffles. What this setting will do is that it will apply heat to the bread or the waffle slowly but longer, so what you will get in the end is the same as if it was fresh and you had just bought it from a bakery.
- Lift Lever. The lift lever in toasters helps a lot with pushing the bread up when they don’t pop up by themselves. Many toasters have this option, but some of them don’t have it. So, if you think you might burn your hands while trying to pick up the rest of the bread, make sure the toaster of your choice has one.
- Shade Setting. The ability to choose your toast shades may be an underrated function but is essential nonetheless. While you may think that the shade setting is controlled by the time the toaster gets to work, and it sometimes does, you can better control the shade on your toast through the browning scale. Therefore, if you are invested in how much shade your toast has without compromising the crispness, you should opt for toasters with a large browning scale.
- Check. This feature is one of my favorite toasters. The check feature is handy if you want to monitor your toast. You can continue from where you stopped if you are not satisfied with the progress. Some toasters have this function, so prioritize it.
- A bit more. This function extends the toasting period if you are unsatisfied with the result. It is usually tagged as “a little longer” or “a bit more” on toasting machines. This function is good for flexibility, and checking out toasters with one is recommended.
Do you really need a toaster?
While you can make toasts in the oven or even on a hot, dry frying pan, a toaster is the fastest and easiest way to brown your bread.
Should I buy a 2 or 4 slice toaster?
It depends on how many people will be using the toaster. If you are buying a new device for one, then a 2-slice model should be enough. For a family, a 4-slice toaster would be more convenient to use.
What is the easiest toaster to clean?
Models with non-stick interiors and removable bread trays are typically the easiest to clean.
Does a toaster use a lot of electricity?
No. On average, toasters use around 800 – 1,500 watts when operating.
Why would the power rating of toasters be different?
Because different models have different heating elements that convert the energy from the power outlet to radiate heat. The faster a toaster can brown the bread, the higher the power rating it would have.
Choosing a good toaster isn’t a hard task, don’t you agree?
All you have to do is remember that the power rating matters if you want your toasts fast. Plus, don’t forget to check for extra features and read the warranty conditions, especially if you are planning to invest in a more expensive model.
And if you are still hesitant, I want to recommend looking at the 2-slice Breville toaster. This one is sized perfectly for solo users or smaller kitchens. Plus, it comes with a nice set of features and allows for adjustments so that you can achieve the perfect brown color of your bread.
How brown do you like your toasts? And which toaster managed to impress you the most? Share your thoughts in the comments!
- Sarah Kate Gillingham (October 12, 2009). 10 Best Uses for Your Toaster Oven. Retrieved from https://www.thekitchn.com/10-great-uses-the-your-toaster-98292
- Alice Williams (n.d.). How to buy the best toaster. Retrieved from https://www.which.co.uk/reviews/toasters/article/how-to-buy-the-best-toaster#type
Hours of Research