TOP 5 Best Mattresses in a Box in Canada

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen products, which earn us a commission at no additional cost for you. Learn More

Written by: Alex Savy
Last updated on

Do you know that feeling when you wake up tired? As if you didn’t sleep at all?
This happens when your bed is not comfortable enough.

To save you from this nightmare, I have prepared my review of the best mattresses in a box in Canada. So, let’s find out which mattress can become the savior of your good night’s sleep!

A Quick Preview

Douglas Mattress
Puffy Mattress
Puffy Mattress
Novosbed Mattress
The Osgoode Mattress
The Osgoode
GhostBed Luxe Mattress
GhostBed Luxe

Our Reviews of 5 Best Mattresses in Canada (January 2024)

Best Overall - Editor’s Choice — Douglas Mattress

Douglas Mattress


  • medium feel to cater to a wide range of sleepers;
  • breathable and moisture-wicking cover for cooler sleep;
  • superb motion isolation, great for couples and restless sleepers;
  • resilient transition layer to combat the quicksand sensation;
  • 120-night sleep trial to guarantee each shopper’s satisfaction.


The Douglas mattress is my editor’s choice due to its coolness, sinkage, and excellent price point. It doesn’t matter if you’re a back, side, stomach or combination sleeper; the Douglas mattress will make you sleep comfortably. I discovered that the latex foam layers ensure that this mattress stays cooler than those produced with memory foam. However, this mattress didn’t hug my body like the other memory foam mattresses I reviewed. The Douglas had a sinkage of 1.92 inches, which is 0.78 inches firmer than the GhostBed Luxe. Looking at both models, the Douglas would better suit sleepers who prefer less contour that could interfere with ease of movement.

Side sleeping
Side sleeping

The medium-firm feel was as impressive as I imagined, and the pressure relief capabilities were notable once I slept on the mattress. However, one area I didn’t like was the edge support. I found the edge support on the Douglas mattress to be below average, so sleepers who prefer sleeping on their mattress’s perimeter might be underwhelmed. Perhaps the most impressive thing about this mattress is the affordable price point. I didn’t find many products that can compete with the excellent value of the Douglas mattress. The Douglas was priced $500 cheaper than the Puffy, $600 cheaper than the Novosbed, and $700 cheaper than the GhostBed Luxe. However, the Douglas still offers similar contouring, pressure relief, and a responsive classic memory foam feel.

Based on Our Tests 

After sleep testing the Douglas mattress, what stood out for me was how different layers of foams are combined to make this mattress bouncy, supportive, and cool. The top layer of cooling memory foam helps draw heat away from the body while the second layer of responsive Elastex foam offers a satisfying bounce to ease movement.

Edge support of the Douglas Mattress

Douglas Mattress Firmness

Best Pressure Relief Mattress — Puffy Mattress

Puffy Mattress


  • Whether you are a back sleeper, side sleeper, or stomach sleeper, this mattress is designed to suit all sleeping positions.
  • Boasts a good balance of comfort and support with cooling on the side.
  • The ultimate spinal alignment for pressure relief. 
  • Decent edge support to offer more sleeping space.

The Puffy mattress features a comfortable cushion that stood out during my review. This mattress is an all-rounder, and the quality stands out among other Canadian beds I reviewed. I appreciated the Puffy mattress’s construction which comprises five foam layers. These foam layers combined to offer me a firm and comfy sleeping platform.

“Side sleepers between 130 and 230 pounds enjoyed the mix of comfort and support the Puffy provided. Those over 230 pounds still found enough support to feel comfortable,” says Dr. Michael Breus of Sleep Doctor.

While testing, the Puffy had compressions of 2.5 inches, which was more than enough for pressure relief and a generous body hug. The Puffy had deeper compressions than the GhostBed Flex by 0.55 inches, making the Puffy a more contouring option for sleepers who prefer sleeping ‘in’ their mattress.

Back sleeping
Back sleeping

The foam layers are covered by a breathable fabric which I found to be cool-to-touch and lightweight. Remember the five foam layers we discussed earlier? These layers also offer top-tier pressure-relieving capabilities, which I found impressive. When I was reviewing the Puffy, it took the upper layers 1.7 seconds to fully bounce back from compressions, making the foam slow-adaptive for adequate pressure relief. The Puffy was 0.9 slower than the Douglas mattress, making the Puffy the one with a more classic memory foam feel out of the two.

This mattress also feels cool so that you can sleep cool in the hot summer months. I found the edge support adequate, so there weren’t too many issues when I rested on the bed’s edges. Overall, the Puffy mattress offers helpful features that make it my second choice for the best mattress in a box in Canada.

Based on Our Tests 

Although our tester is a side sleeper and did feel the mattress conforming to his body, I feel this mattress is ideal for sleepers of all positions. Its medium plush feel is comfortable for most side, back, stomach, and mixed sleepers, although personal preference makes a big difference.

Puffy Mattress-41

Puffy Mattress-195

Best for Hot Sleepers — Novosbed Mattress

Novosbed Mattress


  • 3 firmness options to choose from, suited for different types of users and sleeping positions;
  • natural Tencel cover for improved breathability;
  • close conforming for targeted pressure relief and effective weight distribution;
  • machine-washable cover for fuss-free maintenance;
  • open-cell comfort foam for cooler sleep.

The Novosbed is best for hot sleepers due to its high-quality materials, comfort, and coolness. Firstly, this mattress comes in a great design constructed with high-quality materials that offer a sturdy sleeping surface during testing. I noticed that this mattress feels medium firm and springy. The Novosbed mattress is made using memory foam for the comfort layers and polyfoam for support. I discovered that the memory foam layers contoured nicely around my body, and the sinkage was more than adequate. From my review, I recorded 1.92 inches of sinkage while lying in the Novosbed, 0.03 inches firmer than the GhostBed Flex. That makes both mattresses excellent for contouring while still feeling supportive and keeping the spine straight.

“Sleeping comfortably in the side position can result in many benefits, such as reduced lower back pain, lower risk of snoring, and better bodily health.” says sleep expert Dr. Nilong Vyas, a Pediatrician at Sleep Foundation. This is why mattresses like the Novosbed are so crucial, as they can provide the necessary contour for comfortable side sleeping.

The Tencel fabric cover on the mattress made me feel cool, and I was impressed that the material felt cool to the touch and soft. While testing the Novosbed, the surface temperature got up to 29.5 degrees Celsius while in use. This is 2.5 degrees cooler than the GhostBed Luxe, meaning the Novosbed is the better option for hot sleepers. Another thing I love about the Novosbed bed is its pressure-relieving capabilities, and sleepers suffering from joint pain will find this mattress very effective at relieving painful symptoms.

Showing the Tencel cover
Showing the Tencel cover

In my opinion, the Novosbed performs admirably in many of my review parameters, making it the best mattress in a box in Canada

Bottom line:

The Novosbed is a very versatile mattress. Moreover, it uses high-quality materials and has a rather luxurious feel. I’m sure that it has all the chances to satisfy almost any user.

Based on Our Tests

While testing the Novosbed, my favorite feature was how the mattress regulates temperature, and it's thanks to the open air cell foam construction. So I wholeheartedly recommend this mattress for people who have a habit of sweating and want to enjoy more cooling at night.

Sleeping on the back on the Novosbed mattress


Best Spring Option — The Osgoode

The Osgoode Mattress Review


  • It is made of Tencel and coils that help to draw away heat, keeping hot sleepers cooler.
  • The coils have a reinforced middle that helps to lift the hips and keep the spine in healthy alignment.
  • The comfort layer and coils respond quickly to weight and pressure, creating a restriction-free sleep surface.

The Osgoode is my best spring option due to its excellent price, high bounce, and quick response.

The Osgoode spring mattress comes at an excellent price due to its simple yet conforming design. It is $800 less expensive than the Puffy and $300 less expensive than the Douglas. Despite this price gap, The Osgoode performs better than both of these mattresses in bounce and responsiveness.

Bounce goes hand in hand with spring mattresses like The Osgoode. From my compression tests, I measured a bounce of 7.3 inches. This is high enough that active couples can use the full width of the mattress without worrying about any restrictions on movement. 

The Osgoode had more bounce than the Douglas mattress by 1.86 inches. I would recommend The Osgoode to sleepers who want as much freedom of movement and buoyancy as possible for a cheaper price.

Bounce of The Osgoode Mattress

The Osgoode has excellent response timing due to its high-density foam layer, which reacts quickly to pressure. When I was doing compression tests with this mattress, I measured a recovery speed of 0.4 seconds. This is fast enough that I felt sleepers who enjoy a modern foam feel with their spring mattresses would find a good suit with The Osgoode.

The Osgoode outperformed the Puffy in recovery by 1.3 seconds. I would suggest The Osgoode to any sleeper who enjoys sinking into their mattress slightly but with complete freedom of movement whenever they want to change positions.

Based on Our Tests

The holofil quilt over the high-density foam comfort layer helped even out the pressure during my hand compression tests, giving the impression that sleepers would get a ‘weightless’ feeling while lying down on this bed.

The OsgoodeMattress Firmness
The Osgoode Mattress Thickness

Best Memory Foam Mattress — GhostBed Luxe

GhostBed Luxe


  • Cool-to-the-touch cover with excellent heat dispersion qualities to keep you feeling cool.
  • Soft firmness for extra contouring and plush comfort for effective tension release.
  • Has responsive layers so you don’t feel ‘stuck’ in the memory foam.

The GhostBed Luxe is my best memory foam as it has thick sinkage, excellent motion isolation, and a high amount of bounce. Thick sinkage is one of the best ways a memory foam mattress can relieve pressure, and the GhostBed Luxe has some of the highest sinkage rates I’ve tested. I recorded 2.7 inches, which is 0.2 inches more than the Puffy. This means the GhostBed Luxe can cradle and mold to the body’s shape more, and create a feeling of ‘weightlessness’.

Another feature that I think is helpful regarding the GhostBed Luxe is its ability to isolate motion. Motion isolation is beneficial for sleepers who share the bed with a restless partner or pet, as the absorbent layers can reduce motion transfer. From my tests, the GhostBed Luxe absorbed motion up to 3 inches away from my glass of water, which is on the higher side. I didn’t notice most of my partner’s tossing and turning during the testing period. The GhostBed Luxe was only 0.5 inches behind the Puffy in regards to motion isolation, making both similar in their ability to reduce jostling during the night.

Testing the motion transfer
Testing the motion transfer

The GhostBed Luxe, despite its high sinkage, offers a high amount of bounce. I recorded 8.01 inches for its total bounce value, meaning it’s springy. I could easily shift positions during my testing period with this model. The GhostBed Luxe had 1.22 inches more bounce than the Novosbed, meaning the GhostBed Luxe is the better option of the two for ease of movement.

Based on Our Tests

From my review, the GhostBed Luxe had excellent contouring and deep sinkage for a traditional memory foam feel. However, I never felt restricted in my movement, and could easily change from my back to my side.

Side sleeping on the GhostBed Luxe mattress

GhostBed Luxe Firmness

Why You Should Trust Me

I’ve reviewed a lot of mattresses in Canada by testing them over the course of 5 days to 2 weeks, taking note of their strong and weak points. While testing, I’ve paid special attention to support, pressure relief, motion isolation, thermoregulation, and composition to narrow down the products. Each of these factors determine whether a mattress can perform well in different situations, such as when sleeping with a partner, during hot nights, or after a long day of work dealing with back or shoulder pain. I also take into consideration factors like price, warranty, sleep trial, and manufacturer credibility.

Based on the above factors, the 5 products on this list ranked higher among all the other mattresses. To verify and finalize these choices, I’ve determined whether the layer composition and material making up these mattresses can provide pressure relief and back support. Having all the pieces of the puzzle put together with the help of my methodologies and first-hand experience, I have prepared this list to help you make better decisions when making purchases. 

What to Look for In a Good Mattress In a Box: Buyer’s Guide

I know that searching for a new mattress can be rather stressful.

What to Look for In a Good Mattress In a Box

Here’s the thing though:

If you know what to look for, the shopping process becomes much easier (and stress-free, ideally). So, in order to be prepared, you might want to consider the following aspects:

  • Support. Proper support and weight distribution during the night can help your body maintain a healthy sleeping posture (which can also help you avoid aches and pain in the morning) (1). A good mattress should have a sturdy, thick base layer that could easily accommodate your body weight. Thicker coils or high-density foam are preferable in this case. Also, make sure you choose the correct firmness level for your body type and preferred sleeping position (which we have discussed above). “A mattress that isn’t firm enough will cause your hips and stomach to sink too deeply. This can cause discomfort and misalignment to your spine,” says Dr. Abhinav Singh, a sleep medicine physician at Sleep Foundation.
  • Pressure relief. This aspect is especially important if you have sensitive joints or want instant relaxation. A mattress with good pressure-relieving properties has to conform closely to one’s body and fill in the curves (basically, hug the body gently). In this scenario, you might want to give your preference to memory foam or hybrid mattresses that have extra-thick comfort layers.
  • Motion isolation (for partnered sleep). If one of you is a restless sleeper, your mattress must absorb shock from motion well (if you don’t want to disturb each other during sleep, that is). Memory foam shows the best results in this category, but you can also consider latex and hybrid mattresses with thick foam comfort layers.
  • Temperature regulation. I bet you would agree that sleeping hot is extremely uncomfortable. To avoid that, choose latex or hybrid mattresses, as they are neutral in terms of temperature. If you are a fan of memory foam, pick a model that uses either open-cell or gel-infused foams.
  • Company reputation. Buying a mattress online can seem risky, so it won’t hurt to choose only among reputable companies. To find one, you can simply read other users’ reviews. See how the company you are considering handles negative reviews and deals with returns to get at least a general idea.
  • Warranty and sleep trial. These two aspects will protect you as a customer, so pay attention to them when shopping. An extended warranty can mean that the manufacturer uses quality materials and can be sure of the product’s durability. As for the sleep trial, it will give you a chance to test the new mattress and see whether it works for your body and sleeping position.
  • Safety certifications (especially if you are a sensitive user). Some mattresses use harmful chemicals and fire-retardants during the manufacturing process, which can be an issue for many sleepers (2). Therefore, to stay safe, look for such certifications as Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS), CertiPur, OEKO-TEX, etc.
  • Edge support. This aspect might be crucial, but only in certain scenarios. For instance, you may require stronger edge support if you and your partner need more space but don’t want to buy a larger mattress. With stronger edges, you can sleep closer to one without worrying about rolling off during the night. Reliable edge support may also come in handy for back pain sufferers who find it a bit harder to get out of bed due to pain. Stronger edges will provide more support and a little boost for you to get up.
  • Quality materials. When shopping for a new mattress in a box, you probably want your investment to be a long-lasting one. That’s why it’s crucial to pay attention to the quality of the materials. Now, if we’re talking about memory foam, consider the density rating. As a rule of thumb, the denser the foam is, the more durable it’s going to be. The same rule applies to latex. Although, keep in mind that denser foam and latex often have a firmer feel. And if you’re thinking about purchasing a hybrid or an innerspring mattress, look at the coil gauge rating. A lower rating would mean thicker (and more durable) coils.
  • Mattress cover. Of course, every mattress comes with a cover, whether it is detachable or not. The durability of your mattress can be down to how you maintain your mattress cover. Mattresses can either have a stain-resistant cover or not. The mattress cover can also be detachable or not. It is good to opt for a stain-resistant mattress cover and better to go for a detachable stain-resistant cover. On the other hand, make sure to check if the mattress cover is hypoallergenic. Hypoallergenic covers stop dust, dust mites, and other allergens that can irritate entering your mattress.
  • Price. Price matters in everything. Whether you are on a budget or simply looking for the best quality around, price still plays a role. As a thumb rule, quality always attracts more fees. This may not be the only reason for highly-priced mattresses, but it's common to well-priced beds.  The brand and luxury being promised also add to the cost of a mattress. Spending more mostly assures quality, luxury, and durability. So, if you are looking for these criteria - which I know you are - you shouldn’t be fearful of paying for premium and exclusiveness.
  • Versatility. Everyone has a primary reason for getting a mattress. However, it won't be unheard of to want to use your bed in another capacity - say, use an adjustable frame. A versatile mattress will come in handy in situations like this. Versatility is one thing you should consider if you intend to use your bed for multiple functions.

Also read: Best Mattresses for Back Pain

How to Pick the Best Mattress in a Box

When it comes to finding the absolute best mattress in a box in Canada, there’s one little secret you should know.

You just need to find a model that would suit your specific needs. It’s that simple.

You see, because our bodies are different, we have different requirements when it comes to sleep. So, the main goal here is to find what works for us.

Now, different types of mattresses can be suitable for different sleepers. 

Let’s take a closer look at each.

Memory Foam

Being one of the most popular types, memory foam mattresses offer that pleasant hugging feel that so many of us like. What makes this material so comfortable for sleep is its ability to adjust to the shape of one’s body. Memory foam cradles the protruding parts of the body and helps reduce the tension in pressure points. It allows sufficient sinkage while keeping the spine in a neutral position. 

However, because foam has its “memory”, it might start tearing and wearing off in the spots of the most frequently applied pressure.

The good news is, you can delay that by regularly rotating your mattress.

Now, we all know that memory foam tends to sleep hot. The material itself does not contribute to air circulation. Additionally, let’s not forget about that famous hugging feel. 

Here’s the kicker, though:

Many manufacturers use foam with an open-cell structure, which helps with thermoregulation. Additionally, it is common to infuse foam with gel for a cooling effect.

Also read: TOP 4 Best Memory Foam Mattresses in Canada

Along with memory foam, some mattresses use polyurethane foam. These two materials are chemically related and share some features, such as an ability to conform to body curves. Yet, polyfoam has quicker response and feels bouncier and cooler than memory foam.


Coil mattresses are probably the oldest type of beds. However, don’t confuse them with the squeaky old-school horror we all remember. Modern manufacturers use high-quality coils and pocketed designs to eliminate the noise while ensuring comfort, support, and air circulation. 

Innerspring beds typically have strong edges, which enlarges the sleeping space. They offer bouncy support and have responsive surfaces. This means they are not that great in terms of motion isolation but allow for easy moving around the mattress surface. 

Here’s the good news:

Innerspring mattresses are usually sold at very affordable prices. They are also great for temperature regulation since the coils allow for unobstructed air circulation. This type of mattress is great for stomach and back sleepers since it provides a great deal of bounce and firmer support.


If you are looking for a more natural option, you should definitely consider a latex mattress. But keep in mind that there are both synthetic and natural latex mattresses out there, which means you need to read the “fine print” before purchasing. Another thing you should know is that most latex mattresses are delivered in their full size. So, it might be challenging to find a latex mattress shipped in a box.

Now, latex mattresses have a unique feel. They offer great pressure-relieving properties but not that much sinkage (especially when compared to foam models). At the same time, latex has a springy structure, which makes such mattresses quite bouncy and responsive. 

It gets better:

This type is great for people who hate sleeping hot. Latex allows for natural air circulation and, again, doesn’t hug the body as closely as memory foam does. These mattresses tend to be more durable than foam and innerspring beds. However, keep in mind that latex models are typically more expensive and heavier. 

It’s always a good idea to invest in a mattress protector, especially if the cover is non-removable. This will help prolong its life and keep it fresh at all times.


The name speaks for itself: 

A hybrid is a combination of materials. 

In most cases, such mattresses have an innerspring base layer. As for the comfort layers, here’s where it gets interesting.

Hybrid mattresses allow you to pick exactly what you need according to your personal requirements. Some models use such combinations as pocketed coils + latex, pocketed coils + foam, innerspring block + gel foam + wool, and so on. The list of options can be endless.

So, the choice is entirely up to you. But with so many options comes the main drawback:

You can’t always know how this or that combo will work in the long term for you personally. That’s why don’t forget to do your research and check mattress reviews for every model you are considering.

Many hybrid models have a pillow-top design. The pillow-top part is either sewn into the cover or placed on top of the mattress, hence the name. These mattresses have a very luxurious feel (and look, for that matter). The pillow-top usually adds some plush to balance out the supportive core of the mattress.

Air Mattresses

If you want to buy a mattress in a box, you might want to consider air mattresses as well. Although they are mostly used as a temporary bed, they may offer good comfort and support levels at a very low price. 

Now, airbeds are super portable and allow users to adjust the firmness level by simply deflating or inflating the mattress. 

It gets better:

There are models that allow for adjustments on two sides, which makes them suitable for couples who have different preferences in terms of firmness. 

Body Weight and Mattress Firmness

You can read different mattress reviews from users in Canada that describe the same model in so many different ways. Some people can praise it, others might complain a lot.

Why does it happen, you may ask? Because one bed can work differently for each specific body type.

Body Weight and Mattress Firmness

That’s why it is so important to get the right firmness when shopping for a suitable mattress in a box in Canada. Here are the general tips you should consider:

  • Average sleepers, between 150 and 250 pounds. Generally, such people enjoy medium-firm mattresses, especially back and stomach sleepers. Side sleepers require a bit more cushion, so it’s better to go with the medium firmness.
  • Lightweight sleepers, less than 150 pounds. Petite users need softer mattresses to enjoy the balanced combo of cradling and support. Consider getting yourself a mattress that would be around 3-5 on the firmness scale.
  • Heavier sleepers, more than 250 pounds. Larger individuals oftentimes sink through the comfort layers and hit the support core, which causes unnatural curves in the spine and generally feels quite uncomfortable. To enjoy stronger support and decent contouring, it’s better to get a firm mattress, something around 7.5-8 on the firmness scale.

Keep in mind that every mattress has a break-in period, especially if we are talking about memory foam. It might feel uncomfortable or too firm at first, but after a few nights, it will adjust to your body and the overall feel will change. That’s when you can decide whether you want to keep the mattress or not.

Suitable Firmness for Your Sleeping Position

To get the most out of your new mattress, you need to pick the firmness level that is suitable for your specific sleeping position. Now, this may vary from user to user depending on personal preferences, but here are the general rules:

  • Side sleepers. Since this position requires good pressure relief and a decent amount of cradling for the protruding parts (hips and shoulders), the best option would be a soft mattress. If you are a heavier sleeper, a medium one will work. 
  • Back sleepers. A medium or medium-firm mattress will provide enough cushioning for your hips and buttocks while keeping the spine in a neutral position.
  • Stomach sleepers. For this sleeping position, you will require stronger support. Your mattress should be firm or at least medium-firm to prevent the pelvis from sinking in.
  • Combination sleepers. If you tend to change positions while sleeping, you might enjoy a medium-firm mattress the most. Something not too firm and not too soft will be able to give you balanced support throughout the night.


What is a bed in a box?

A bed in a box is a mattress that is delivered to your doorstep compressed and vacuum-sealed in a box. Upon arrival, you need to unbox your new mattress and give it time to expand (take its normal shape).

Can I get an innerspring or a hybrid mattress in a box?

Yes,many hybrid and spring mattresses can be shipped compressed in a box.

How soon should I unbox my new mattress?

Manufacturers typically recommend unboxing mattresses within 30-60 days to avoid damaging the mattress materials (due to long-term compression).

How long do mattresses in a box last?

Mattresses in a box typically last around 10-15 years, depending on the mattress type.

How can I return a mattress in a box?

Most mattress companies arrange a pick-up if you decide to return the mattress, so you don’t really need to do much. However, some courier companies might ask you to wrap the mattress in plastic before returning it.


When it comes to sleep, the most important component is your mattress. Your mattress alone can either save or ruin your night’s rest.

My pick of the best mattresses was carefully curated to cater to various individual needs. And if you feel constricted by my list, you can always follow the guidelines for picking the best mattress in Canada for yourself.

In my opinion, the Douglas mattress is one of the best options in Canada. It offers an excellent price point, comfortable sinkage, and cooling qualities. It’s helpful for sleepers who tend to run hot during the night.

Still have questions about finding the best mattress in a box in Canada? Alex Savy, the Co-Founder and Chief Editor at Comfynorth has reviewed countless sleep products with over 4 years in the industry and can help you find what you’re looking for. Reach out through email at [email protected]. When emailing Alex, include your full name and phone number or email address.


  1. The Social (March 18). Posture-perfect sleep positions that are right for your body. Retrieved from 
  2. Dawn Yanek (June 15, 2020). 12 Common Bedroom Items that Are Secretly Toxic. Retrieved from

Our research


Mattresses Considered


Hours of Research


Sleep Experts Consulted

Subscribe to get updates and new deals!

Zero spam. Unsubscribe at any time


  1. Bravo, your phrase it is brilliant

Leave a comment