Clicky

Unbiased Mattress Reviews in Canada in 2024

This research is supported by you, our readers, through our independently chosen products, which earn us a commission at no additional cost for you. Learn More

Written by: Alex Savy
Last updated on

Acquiring any product is down to the positives it has to offer. However, no matter the positives, customers do appreciate an unbiased examination of the product in question so as to make better decisions. Therefore, bearing in mind the importance of mattresses to sleep and comfort, we have come up with unbiased mattress reviews in Canada for 2024.

Specific mattresses with their best use case and the criteria considered in choosing them are discussed in the write-up below. Hopefully, our readers are better enlightened on their choice of mattress after reading.

A Quick Overview

IMAGE PRODUCT
Douglas Mattress Check Current Price
GhostBed Luxe Mattress Check Current Price
Novosbed Mattress Check Current Price
The Osgoode Mattress Check Current Price
Puffy Mattress Check Current Price

Our Review of the Top 5 Best Rated Mattress in Canada (January 2024)

Best Overall - Editor’s Choice — Douglas Mattress

Douglas Mattress

Highlights

  • Impressive motion isolation feature for couples;
  • Comes with enhanced edge support for more sleeping space;
  • It features an infrared heat dissipation tech for maintaining a cool surface.

The Douglas mattress is my editor’s choice due to its motion-isolating features, excellent pressure relief, and fair thermoregulation. It is a mattress suited to sleepers with restless partners or significant weight differences. My review showed an acute point elasticity, creating near-perfect conformity to pressure. I recorded a 0.8-second recovery from compressions, and I could feel the slow-adaptive comfort of the foam layers as they took a moment to mold to my body and let me sink in for better pressure relief. This was 0.4 seconds slower than the GhostBed Luxe, meaning the Douglas Original is better for a slow-adaptive feel. “The two inches of contour I felt when testing the Douglas created a comfortable sinking feeling. I sank through the ecoLight® foam to the firmer layers below,” stated Logan Block, a Mattress Reviewer for Sleepopolis.

Side sleeping
Side sleeping

I could sleep comfortably on it due to its good thermoregulation. From my unbiased tests, the Douglas Original had a temperature of 31.8 degrees Celsius, which is cool enough to keep my temperature neutral. It does get close to the recommended maximum of 32.2 degrees, but I felt this model still could keep night sweats at bay. The Douglas Original was 0.2 degrees cooler than the GhostBed Luxe, making the Douglas Original slightly better in heat dispersion. I like the bounciness of the mattress, as it felt quite springy compared to the Puffy mattress. Furthermore, this mattress provided good support for my frame. I also liked that the mattress catered to my pressure points by bending in the right places to accommodate them.

Mattress firmness can indicate how durable the mattress will be. Firmer options tend to be more durable. However, denser means heavier.

Based on Our Tests

This mattress supported my spine, balanced the back, and relieved me of annoying pressure points. I also slept more comfortably without being hot, thanks to the breathable cooling gel foam of the mattress.

Stomach sleeping on the Douglas mattress

Douglas Mattress Firmness

Runner-up — GhostBed Luxe

GhostBed Luxe Mattress

Click on the button below to check price and go shopping

Check current price Read our detailed review
Get 50% OFF

Highlights

  • The cool-to-the-touch cover is soft and heat-dispersing, helping you stay cool and comfortable;
  • The 2 inches of GhostBouce foam help to keep the mattress feeling buoyant and bouncy for ease of movement;
  • The deep cradling sinkage molds and contours to the body for penetrating pressure relief.

The GhostBed Luxe is my runner-up thanks to its excellent sinkage, great motion isolation, and excellent bounce for ease of movement. Sinkage is impactful in how pressure relieves a memory foam mattress is, and the GhostBed Luxe excels in this area. From my unbiased review, the Ghostbed Luxe had a sinkage of 2.7 inches. This is enough sinkage where I was well-cradled, and the top layers noticeably compressed under me, so I was more ‘in’ than ‘on’ the mattress. The GhostBed Luxe was more compressing than the Puffy by 0.2 inches, which means the GhostBed Luxe is better for sleepers who enjoy soft, enveloping sinkage.

Another feature I found helpful regarding the Ghostbed Luxe was its ability to isolate motion. Motion transfer can be troublesome if you’re a light sleeper prone to waking up at the slightest movement from a partner. According to my tests, the GhostBed Luxe reacted to compressions about 3 inches from my compression tests and my glass of water. That’s enough isolation that I found my partner couldn’t feel when I was tossing and turning beside them. The Ghostbed Luxe has better motion-isolating properties than the GhostBed Flex by about 2 inches. That means the Ghostbed Luxe is the better choice for sleepers who need a high level of motion isolation.

Testing the motion transfer
Testing the motion transfer

The GhostBed Luxe also has an excellent bounce rate. Bounce means how springy a mattress feels and can help with ease of movement and avoiding that ‘quicksand’ feel that traditional memory foam mattresses are known for. From my tests, the GhostBed Luxe has an 8.01-inch total bounce due to its Ghost Bounce layer and firm base. I could move across the surface of the mattress relatively easily as the foam bounced back quickly, despite having such deep sinkage. The GhostBed Luxe has 1.22 inches more bounce than the Novosbed, which means the GhostBed Luxe is better suited to sleepers looking for springiness and buoyancy in their mattress.

Based on Our Tests

I determined through my tests that the GhostBed Luxe, thanks to its excellent sinkage, is incredibly comfortable while I’m on my side. It cradles the shoulders and hips nicely while keeping my spine neutral.

Side sleeping on the GhostBed Luxe mattress

GhostBed Luxe Firmness

Best for Couples — The Novosbed

Novosbed Mattress

Highlights

  • Optimal support for different sleeping positions and weight categories;
  • Superbly durable side upholstery for the mattress side;
  • Users can request a topper to address any firmness issue with the mattress.

The Novosbed is my best option for couples due to its excellent balance between comfort and support, ease of movement, and excellent motion transfer ability. The Novosbed is a quality mattress I find to be the best bet for different individuals, regardless of their weight and sleeping positions. 

From my tests, I experienced proper support for my frame regardless of my sleeping style. The Novosbed had a sinkage of 1.92 inches, where I found I was cushioned yet still experienced enough support to keep my spine aligned. The Novosbed had 0.58 more sinkage than the Puffy, making the Novosbed more suited to sleepers who enjoy less sinkage and a more even surface for their spine. I could also move around quite easily, although this was more prominent in the firm version.

Back sleeping
Back sleeping

Despite the ease of movement, the Novosbed could absorb motion rather well. Motion absorption is crucial for light sleepers who share the bed with a partner who is always on the move in their sleep. From my unbiased tests, the Novosbed reacted to compressions around 2 inches from my glass of water. My partner could barely feel this high level of motion isolation when I got in and out of bed. The Novosbed has better motion isolation than the GhostBed Flex by 3 inches, making the Novosbed the better model overall for sleepers needing high motion absorption. Ultimately, I think the Novosbed is great for providing options that cater to a wide range of users.

Based on Our Tests

I was able to test the soft version of the mattress. It conforms to the contours of my body, and it feels plush, but you won't feel like you're sinking into quicksand.

Cover

Side sleeping on the Novosbed mattress

Best Affordable Option — The Osgoode

The Osgoode Mattress Review

Highlights

  • The Tencel and breathable coils help draw heat away, keeping hot sleepers from overheating.
  • This model comes with competitive pricing that allows sleepers with tight budgets to get restful sleep.
  • The reinforced middle of this mattress helps to keep the spine neutral, keeping sleepers more comfortable.

The Osgoode is my best affordable option due to its budget-friendly price, quick response, and excellent bounce. 

Price is one of the first factors sleepers look at when choosing a mattress. The Osgoode offers a well-rounded price that is more accessible to a broader variety of budgets. The Osgoode is $850 less expensive than the Puffy and $600 less costly than The Summerhill. Despite the price difference, The Osgoode still has a comparable response.

Response is a key factor of freedom of movement in a mattress. During my compression tests with this model, I measured a pushback response rate of 0.4 seconds. This is fast enough that I felt sleepers who prefer a modern, buoyant feel to their spring mattress would enjoy The Osgoode.

The Osgoode outperformed the Puffy in this regard by 1.3 seconds. However, The Summerhill responded slightly faster by 0.1 seconds. I would recommend The Osgoode for sleepers who want a mix of value and fast response. However, for sleepers who want the fastest response speed, The Summerhill is the one to go with.

Bounce is another factor that stood out to me when evaluating The Osgoode. From my hand compression tests and unbiased review, I measured a bounce of roughly 7.3 inches. This is high enough that I felt that, for a spring mattress, The Osgoode would ensure sleepers could enjoy fast movement and move unhindered across the bed.

Bounce of The Osgoode Mattress

The Osgoode outperformed the Douglas in this regard by a considerable margin - 1.86 inches. I would recommend The Osgoode to active couples and sleepers who want a bouncy and buoyant feel in their sleep surface.

“Some of the most compelling benefits of spring mattresses are that they’re generally affordable, responsive, bouncy, and provide excellent airflow for a cooler sleep,” explained Danny Noyed, a Senior Product Editor at Sleep Foundation.

Based on Our Tests

While completing my hand compression tests with this model, I found The Osgoode responsive. I enjoyed its moderate pushback, giving me the impression that sleepers would enjoy freedom of movement with this model.

The Osgoode Mattress Thickness
The OsgoodeMattress Firmness

Best Memory Foam Mattress — Puffy Mattress

Puffy Mattress

Click on the button below to check price and go shopping

Check current price Read our detailed review
Get $300 OFF + FREE Pillow

Highlights

  • This mattress is designed to work with any frame, including adjustable frames;
  • Excellent mattress serves the body’s pressure points, aiding the body’s relaxation;
  • Comes with a lifetime warranty.

The Puffy is my best memory foam mattress thanks to its excellent sinkage, motion isolation, and contouring ability. My tests confirm that the Puffy mattress is one of the best medium-firm mattresses available. The balance of this mattress's sinkage, motion isolation, and bounce features makes it a good option for the average sleeper. 

Looking at the mattress’s sinkage, I noticed the top layers compressed considerably under my weight. From my unbiased review, the Puffy had a compression of 2.5 inches, which is enough for effective cradling and weight redistribution. The Puffy had 0.55 inches more sinkage than the GhostBed Flex, making the Puffy the better option for a deep-cradling feel.

The highest quality memory foam mattresses can isolate motion, and the Puffy is no exception. From my tests, the Puffy reacted to compressions around 2.5 inches from my glass of water, enough that my partner couldn’t feel it when I got in and out of bed. The Puffy had 2.5 inches better motion isolation than the GhostBed Flex, which means the Puffy is a more suitable option for light sleepers who need to remain undisturbed while sleeping.

Testing the motion transfer
Testing the motion transfer

A mattress’s contouring ability is another feature that makes a good memory foam mattress great. This is how long it takes for the foam to bounce back after being compressed and helps with how pressure-relieving a mattress is. According to my tests, the Puffy took 1.7 seconds to bounce back fully from compressions, and I could feel it slow-adapt to my body for a deeper, more contouring feel. This is 1.3 seconds slower than the GhostBed Luxe, making the Puffy a more suitable option for sleepers who want more pressure relief and a slower-adapting foam mattress.

On the other hand, the support wasn’t lacking because I did not feel any unnatural bends on my body while resting. Considering my experience with this mattress, I think this mattress is better for side sleepers and back sleepers who need sufficient cushion.

Based on Our Tests

My tests showed me the pressure alleviating properties of this mattress as it cradled my body's pressure points. This provides precise contouring, promoting healthy body alignment and relieving pressure in areas like hips and shoulders.

Stomach sleeping on the Puffy mattress

Sitting on the Puffy mattress

Why You Should Trust Me

Over the years, we at ComfyNorth have reviewed countless mattresses in person. We have years of industry knowledge to offer and know the difference between a well-made and a poor-quality mattress. Our mattresses undergo rigorous testing to determine comfort, pressure relief, motion isolation, and support. We also look at other factors, such as temperatures for coolness and edge support.

When it comes to determining the best mattresses from an unbiased review, we chose the best mattresses in the categories of comfort, motion isolation, and pressure relief to add to this list. All of the mattresses in this list excel in these categories. You can read our mattress-testing process here to learn more about our methodology.

How to Choose the Best Mattresses in Canada

While honest mattress reviews are all good, knowing how to choose the best mattress is better. What makes the best mattresses unique? What criteria for selecting the best mattresses in Canada? Here are some tips for picking the best mattresses. 

How to Choose the Best Mattresses in Canada

Mattress Type

There are different types of mattresses, up to 15 types. However, the common ones are 

  1. Memory Foam Mattresses: This type is the most common mattress, and it is known for its motion isolation features. It also has the conforming characteristic necessary for embracing pressure points in the body(1). 
  2. Hybrid Mattresses: Hybrid mattresses are mattresses made from two materials, especially foam and innerspring. They are pretty durable and also offer incredible bounce(2).
  3. Latex Mattresses: This type of mattress is known for its long life span. They are made from plant fibers and provide a good bounce for users. Although this mattress sleeps hot, manufacturers tend to use it with gel-infused foams. 
  4. Innerspring Mattresses: Innerspring mattresses are like hybrid mattresses but with more springs for support and bounce. “Innerspring mattresses with lots of study coils are more durable and will last longer than most all-foam mattresses,” according to Joanne Chen of the NYTimes.

Certifications

Mattresses primarily provide comfort but should not be detrimental to healthy sleeping. This is why potential buyers should check for health certifications for any mattress they are interested in purchasing. The common ones are OEKO-tex and CertiPUR-US.

Thickness and Density

Mattress thickness and density are often used interchangeably, but they are two distinct mattress characteristics.

The mattress thickness often refers to how high the mattress is when laid in its natural position, while mattress density refers to how solid it is. So, for example, a firm mattress option will be denser than the soft option even though they may have the same thickness. 

The essence of not conflating a mattress’ thickness with the density is because of durability. Dense mattresses tend to last longer than less dense ones, irrespective of thickness.   

Mattress thickness and density

Firmness

Firmness is an important quality to check for in an honest mattress review. The firmness level of the mattress determines whether the mattress will be usable for an individual. The different sleeper types and combinations have preferred firmness levels. A wrong firmness level that negates the user's favorite sleeping position will only result in ache. 

Most mattresses in Canada create their mattresses in the medium firmness range to cater to more people. While there are recommended firmness levels for each sleeper type, this is an excellent way to ensure more people are satisfied, especially couples with different sleeping styles. 

If the firmness level is still unsatisfactory, mattress toppers can be used to achieve the desired level by adding the soft option to a firm mattress and vice versa. While some companies offer this topper for free, some offer them for purchase. 

Sleeping Hot

Everyone likes a cool mattress surface. The issue arises when the mattress cannot stay cool during usage, causing discomfort. While some mattresses tend to retain body heat on the surface due to the materials used for construction, top mattress brands have techs and designs for their mattresses to dissipate heat from the surface to keep the mattress surface cool. 

Some of the things to check for in a mattress for a cool surface include gel-infused foam layers, breathable covers, and some other custom tech aimed at helping with body heat. 

Sleep Trials and Guarantees

Sleep trials and guarantees usually indicate the trust of manufacturers in their products. For example, most mattresses have sleep trials not less than 90 days and have guarantees greater than ten years. These two criteria are the baseline requirements for a mattress’ guarantee. 

The sleep trial is for checking if an individual enjoys sleeping on the mattress. Returning is usually within the sleep trial period, and most of these mattress manufacturers offer free shipping and returns if the mattress is not satisfactory.  

Cleaning

Mattresses need cleaning every once in a while, mainly if used for an extended period. While cleaning mattresses is totally possible and even encouraged, it is not an easy task. An easy way to achieve an ever-fresh bed is by cleaning the mattress cover, which is only possible if the cover is detachable. It is important to check if the mattress cover is detachable because it can save users a lot of potential stress.

FAQs

What type of mattress is the best?


There is no definitive answer to this as the best mattress type depends on the individual's preference, especially sleeping position.

What mattress kind is the most durable?


Generally, latex mattresses tend to last longer than their counterparts, but mattresses with a highly dense core are assured to be durable with a long life span.

Conclusion

In conclusion of our unbiased mattress reviews, it is essential to note what separates the mattresses mentioned here. Their excellent attributes are a significant reason we have provided a guide for our readers to ease the task when trying to choose a mattress for themselves.

In my opinion, the Douglas Original mattress is what stood out to me the most as the best in my list. The Douglas Original has an excellent price point, and I found its motion isolation properties excellent. I could toss and turn, and my partner remained undisturbed. It also had a slow-adaptive feel, giving me better pressure relief and keeping my muscles tension-free and comfortable.

Still have questions about finding the best mattress in Canada? Alex Savy, the Co-Founder and Chief Editor at Comfynorth has reviewed countless sleep products with over 4 years in the industry and can help you find what you’re looking for. Reach out through email at [email protected]. When emailing Alex, include your full name and phone number or email address.

References:

  1. Mattress firm blog. (2018, July 8). 5 Benefits of Buying a Memory Foam Mattress. Retrieved from https://www.mattressfirm.com/blog/mattress-obsessed/the-benefits-of-buying-a-memory-foam-mattress
  2. Casper blog. (2021, August 23). What is a hybrid mattress? Retrieved from https://casper.com/blog/what-is-hybrid-mattress/#:~:text=A%20hybrid%20mattress%20is%20a,Talk%20about%20the%20perfect%20blend!

Our research

22

Mattresses Considered

100

Hours of Research

2

Sleep Experts Consulted

Subscribe to get updates and new deals!

Zero spam. Unsubscribe at any time

Leave a comment